Note:
The information contained in this article applies to
California residents only. Residents outside
of California should contact an attorney for
information on the laws in their area.
One
of the fundamental joys of life for many of us is
the unconditional love and companionship of a dog,
cat or other domestic animal. Some of us even feel
"owned" by our four-legged creatures, and
see them as members of our own family. In planning
the disposition and succession of our estates,
however, we often neglect to consider arrangements
for the care of our pets after our own deaths. As a
result, many formerly pampered animals end up in
shelters awaiting adoption or are simply put to
death because they cannot be placed owing to age,
ill-health or bad temperament.
Studies
have confirmed the benefits of pet ownership for the
elderly living alone, including improved mental and
physical health, often resulting in greater
longevity. Yet many elderly individuals are
reluctant to acquire a pet because they are
concerned, understandably, that the animal will
outlive them and will have no home after their
death. Sadly, they deprive themselves of a
relatively inexpensive way to improve greatly their
personal environment. A simple solution exists to
address their concerns: making advance arrangements
for a new home in the event they predecease their
pet.
Those
of us who are pet owners should take steps to ensure
that our pets continue to have a home after our
deaths. It takes only a small effort to provide for
our trusted and loyal companions (a dog's loyalty
is, of course, unquestioned; cats are loyal, too, so
long as you feed them) for their role in enhancing
our lives.
Planning
for the care of our pets is not so simple as leaving
a sum of money directly to them. No matter what
human attributes we may ascribe to our pets, under
California law they do not qualify as
"persons" entitled to receive such
bequests. Therefore, an animal can do nothing with a
cash bequest without the assistance of a
"person".
We
may, however, provide for our pets in other ways.
This article will explore several different options
for achieving that goal.
Finding
a Dependable Caretaker
Whether
you plan to provide for your pets formally or
informally, the critical first step is to identify a
trusted family member or friend who is willing to
assume responsibility for their care. Reviewing with
your successor caretaker your day-to-day routine,
the degree to which you have hopelessly spoiled your
pets and any special health issues will give him or
her a good idea of what to expect. Once you have
found the ideal successor servant, um, I mean master,
you may wish to write him or her a letter
memorializing your agreement.
Even
though you may feel comfortable with these informal
arrangements for your pets' welfare, it is still
wise to document your plan by including a provision
describing your agreement in your will or living
trust. Your caretaker will then be reminded of his
or her promise to you, and may feel an increased
moral obligation to honor what is otherwise an
unenforceable commitment.
The
easiest method for providing for your pet is simply
to "bequeath" him or her to your selected
caretaker. "As we discussed before my death, I
leave my dog Rex to my brother, John Doe." Rex
now belongs to John (or vice versa).
As
an incentive, you may also wish to leave a sum of
money to the caretaker, conditioned upon his
willingness to carry out the agreed upon commitment:
"...together with the sum of $5,000, said funds
to be used to defray the costs of the care of my dog
Rex for the remainder of Rex's life. John may retain
any funds remaining after Rex's death as an
expression of my gratitude for his care of
her."
Depending
upon your compulsion to control from the grave, you
can specify the care John is to provide: "Such
care shall include, but not be limited to, boarding,
feeding of premium pet food and veterinary
care."
Because
no third party is supervising John's activities, his
failure to discharge his responsibilities as you
have directed will be purely a matter of his
conscience. It is of utmost importance, therefore,
that you choose your caretaker wisely.
Authorizing
Your Personal Representative To Supervise the
Adoption and Care of Your Pet
If
you are unable to identify a specific caretaker who
will care for your pet, you can instead direct your
personal representative to arrange for his or her
adoption. You may also give your personal
representative the discretion to pay the new
caretaker a specified sum of money for the pet's
care in his or her new home.
*Note*
Schofield & Grossman has over 25 Years
Experience in the Creation Of Trusts and Wills
If
your estate plan includes a continuing trust, you
can direct the trustee to reimburse the caretaker on
a periodic basis for food and other routine care,
and on a case-by-case basis for any extraordinary
items (illness, injury, etc.). Any funds remaining
after the pet's death can then be distributed either
to the caretaker or to your other beneficiaries. The
charm of this arrangement is that your trustee can
monitor the quality of your pet's care.
Relying
on Charity
Still
another alternative is to approach an organization
willing to care for your pet after your death.
Certain organizations, such as Society for the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, (SPCA), and the
Amanda Foundation, both in greater Los Angeles, will
take in your pet and, assuming no health or
behavioral problems, will arrange for his or her
adoption. Both organizations will place your pet
without charge, but they will, of course, welcome
any contribution you can make to defray the cost of
interim boarding and care. Such deductions are
tax-deductible by your estate if made in the form of
a bequest.
Other
organizations may take in your pet after your death
in exchange for a donation to their cause. In
researching such organizations, you should exercise
the same care as you would when selecting an
individual to care for your pets.
Even
if you have made arrangements with a trusted
caretaker, you can combine the care of your pets
with making a charitable contribution by
participating in a charitable reminder trust
program.
Under
this kind of program, you can make a present
donation of cash or appreciated assets in trust to a
charity. You and the charity agree upon a rate of
return (e.g. seven percent of the trust) which will
be paid to you for your lifetime.
After
your death, for a period or time approximately equal
to your pet's remaining life expectancy, the income
will be paid to the individual you have selected to
care for him or her. At the pet's death, the trust
will terminate and the remaining funds will be
distributed to the charity. A number of
organizations, including SPCA, offer this kind of
program.
When
you make a present gift to the charity, you are
entitled to take a current income tax deduction for
the present value of your gift. You will also avoid
paying capital gains on any appreciated assets used
to fund the trust. Finally, you will remove the
gifted assets from your estate, potentially
decreasing the amount of estate taxes your estate
will pay.
Creating
a Pet Trust
Periodically,
news articles appear about individuals who have left
a portion of their estate in a trust, perhaps even
their home, for the express purpose of allowing
their pets to live out their days in the same
environment as when their owner was alive. After the
pets' death, the "pet trust" assets can
pass to human beneficiaries. For most pet owners
such provision would be considered excessive, but
for those of independent means and a particularly
strong devotion to their four-legged companions,
that option nevertheless exists.
*
* * * *
It
is important to acknowledge that, regardless of our
efforts to provide for our pets, there is no
absolutely fool-proof way to guarantee that they
will be as well cared for once we are gone as they
are now. Nevertheless, making some kind of provision
for them can ease any worries we may have about our
pets outliving us, and can as a result greatly
enhance our golden years by allowing us to enjoy
their company.